During his BC athletic career, Nick was a 4 time 1st team All Ohioan in soccer and was also 1st team All Ohio in football as a sophomore. He led his team to multiple league and district championships during his soccer career, and is currently the OHSAA leader in career assists and assists in a season for all divisions. He earned multiple player of the year honors at the league and district level, and was selected as the Division 3 State player of the year as well as the Gatorade State player of the year for Ohio. Nick continued his soccer career at Indiana University, where he graduated with honors and was a 4 time Academic All Big Ten performer.